Ladies and Gentlemen... Your Helsinki Flyers
So, I know I'm not anyone's first stop for hockey news. I'm also probably not your first stop for analysis of hockey news, either. Not even your first stop for Flyers' hockey news analysis (and it has recently come to my attention that there aren't any good Flyers blogs, while we have a pair of mediocre beat writers). Hell, I'm probably not a stop at all. But I'm a sports blog, and more importantly a Philly sports blog, and I am, above all, a Flyers fan first and foremost, so I should at least pretend to offer incite on these rare, national-attention grabbing occasions. I know, this could all be avoided if we just had Al Morganti back.
Basically, the argument is coming down to four things: the deal, the money, the cap room left, the ethics. And everyone in all the other major markets are--surprise!--pissed off and crying foul, if forum debate is at all reliable. The word from the tri-state area has been--somewhat surprising--mainly positive. Why is that? Flyers fans love offseason splashes, even ill-advised ones. We fuckin' relished the UFA signings of 2005, and we embraced Roenick before his toes hit the ice. Say what you want about their masochistic nature, Philly fans are eternally hopefully, if not optimistic. Let's try and mix the two and deliver a pragmatic view of the deal.
The Deal
There's been cries of foul play and tampering, and fuck it, they are probably right. I've heard murmurs of Homer attending the Bob Clarke School of Backstab General Management (although it's usually put less obtusely). I'm here to propose one further. Look me in the eyes now, viewers:
Which is more logical to you, Bobby Clarke stepping down from the position of GM or Bobby Clarke lulling the league into complacency by pretending to step down, but instead building a Paul Holmgren cyborg and running the show from the comfort of his home.
It makes scary sense (to me). Make Homer look like a sub-par GM with some bad deals (Zhitnik, York), shop off your biggest asset (Forsberg), slowly gain momentum with some sneaky, under-the-radar trades (Coburn, Kukkonen, Biron), before crushing some fucking throat two weeks prior to UFA Day and still having 10 mil plus to give on a top flight center and role players/breathing room.
It should be cleared up here that Nashville GM David Poile got neutered, he just isn’t in a position to care. And it was more by the team’s monetary constrictions than any move by the Flyers. Relocation to Hamilton, already a public reality in Canada, is probably a foregone conclusion anyway, as Nashville ownership (placed in an equally bad bind by the slow purchase process that would transfer for the team bills over to buyer Jim Balsillie) has tightened the purse strings in an attempt to stave off loses—27 million over the past 2 years. They will be unlikely to produce a team capable off outdrawing last year’s group that garnered the third most points in the league, and they must likely do so, and even more, cap a 14,000 seat average, to keep the franchise from optioning to balk on staying. Castration of his ability to do his job aside, Poile did nice in getting the Flyers to send him his pick back, although it's really Homer tipping the dealer after cleaning up at his table.
And that’s why the Flyers—maybe through recognition of the Nashville predicament, maybe not—have been essentially able to trade twentysomething games with Forsberg for Scottie Upshall, Kimmo Timonen, Scott Hartnell, prospect Ryan Parent, and Nashville’s 3rd rounder in this draft. Oh, and Forsberg might be back in Philly by October, anyway.
The deal is solid; there’s no questioning that.
The Money
Yay for sticking points. By money, I mean contracts: as in, 37.8 over 6 years for Timonen (32) and 25.2 for Hartnell (25) over the same period. 6.3 and 4.2 per, respectively. So let’s see, first, if those are/would be the market prices.
The salary cap is expected to rise from 44 mil to 49+ mil, so salaries will once again be inflating ever so slightly. That being said, Timonen was in line for this payday. Markov is getting 5.75, Chara is getting 7.5; he’s somewhere in between, this makes sense. He’s a top-pairing defenseman, a two-time All-Star—we needed one, and that’s the money you have to give to get one. And the contract is front-loaded, so if he slows a step at 36, we can ship him off and some other team will only take a 2.5 per cap hit. Welcome to NFL contracting, puckheads.
As for Hartnell, he was looking for 3.5 from Nashville, and that was his I-really-want-to-stay-here pitch. Someone would sign him for this money, and, looking at his playing style and how he fits in the lineup, I’m glad it’s us.
The Cap Room
Speaking of the lineup, this is a good time to give it an evaluation. We’re sitting at 39.5 with only Pits left to sign, after Rathje retires:
Gagne-(FA Center)-Knuble
Hartnell-Carter-Upshall
Sanderson-Richards-Ruzicka
Eager-Umburger-Kapanen
Or something like that, with Potulny scratched. Can we view a top line center as a done deal? I gotta hope so, since half of this deal is posturing for July 1st. Now it gets tricky. We can assume Rathje is gone, and we should try to eliminate Gauthier and Hatcher as well; hello, cap room. If this does happen, we’ll be at 33.0 and looking positively callipygian. But we’ll probably keep Hatcher (boo). Rumors of payback Pitkanen offer sheets? So welcome on an underperforming youngun’. Homer would love to scout the draft with your four house-money first rounders. Otherwise, hold hope for some premier mentoring on Timonen’s behalf.
Hatcher-Timonen
Pitkanen-Kukkonen
Jones-Coburn
Picard scratched, Oskars Bartulis nearly NHL ready, Ryan Parent a budding phenom, lil’ Timo dare we say thriving under sibling rivalry and Lars Jonsson… well, present and accounted for. Tack on Biron and battle-scarred Nitty, and that, my friends, is a 6 seed.
Best case scenario? We lose Hatcher and Goat, Timonen gels the locker room, Homer spends the extra monies on another top 4 D man and that center we all so desperately desire. Talk is Briere or Gomez; I lean towards the latter.
The Ethics
Something rotten in the state of CBA. Surely an unintentional loophole, one that may be directly addressed in the future. Then again, if it's not playing the system and pissing everyone off, I'm not sure I want to be doing it. For a second straight year, the Flyers blow the shit out of your ways and means, NHL GMs, and in this case, it couldn't get shadier.
What Homer technically acquired was the right to negotiate with Kimmo and Hartnell for 72 hours: on the surface, a risky venture because they could choose not to sign, but this is the Flyers we're talking about, I'm almost positive that no matter how surprised the agents claim to be, we tampered like no tomorrow and had these guys locked up before we touched their rights. The best part (my favorite part) is that no one seems to be considering this the as-of-yet unclarified "future considerations" from the Matt Ellison deal. But doesn't that make sense? Isn't this exactly the kind of considerations you want if you were running a team?
We can't outsign the entire league anymore; this is how you be cutthroat in the cap era. I've about come to grips with any moral dilemmas it takes to win a championship. I would kill a homeless to further the cause. Besides, I'd rather be cheating in the front office than cheating on the ice. You're with me, Left Wing Lock.
Fuckin' Devils.
